Clandestine Entrants and Civil Penalties
Appealing migrant penalties
Our lawyers have a high success rate in overturning clandestine entrant penalties issued to transport companies found carrying illegal migrants into the UK. Our clients include transport and logistics companies across Europe and beyond.
We understand the difficulties facing transport companies operating vehicles into the UK via Northern France, Calais and Coquelles. Every week there are hundreds of attempts by illegal migrants to gain unauthorised access to vehicles en route to the UK. Keeping your vehicle and trailer secure against stowaways can be a challenge.
If the UK Border Force or Customs discovers migrants in one of your vehicles, you may face a heavy fine. Our transport lawyers can help.
Civil Penalties: legal requirements
Under UK law, road transport operators and drivers are both responsible for securing their vehicles against migrants.
The UK Border Force can stop and inspect any vehicle entering the UK. They can fine businesses and drivers up to £2,000 for each migrant found.
Companies can avoid a Notice of Liability to Civil Penalty (IS11D), however to do this the operator will have to demonstrate 3 things:
- That it did not know or suspect that migrants were hiding in the vehicle or trailer,
- That the company operated an effective system to stop migrants being carried, and
- That the system was being properly operated by the driver at the time the vehicle was stopped
It is the responsibility of the company and the driver to show, with evidence, that this defence applies.
Notices of Objection
If you have received a “civil penalty for the carriage of clandestine entrants”, you can write to the Border Force asking them to cancel or reduce the penalty. You will need to provide evidence that you had an “effective system in place” and that “the system was being properly operated”. A written representation of this kind is called a Notice of Objection.
At Rothera Bray we have many years of experience in preparing Notices of Objection on behalf of our UK and European transport clients. We can tell you what evidence you will need to provide and we can write to the Border Force on your behalf.
You only have 28 days to send a Notice of Objection, so if you have received a penalty notice please contact us straight away.
Notices of Objection prepared by our lawyers have an extremely high success rate in reducing or cancelling civil penalties. We can agree a fixed fee with you from the outset so that you have certainty of costs.
Appeals to the County Court
If your Notice of Objection has been unsuccessful, you have the right to appeal against your civil penalty to the County Court in the UK. Hearings of this kind usually take place at Canterbury County Court.
Our lawyers can start court proceedings, prepare your grounds of appeal and help you to gather witness statements and your evidence. Our specialist advocates can represent you at your appeal hearing and present your case.
If necessary we can also seek to negotiate a favourable settlement agreement on your behalf without the need for a court hearing.
We take a pragmatic and open approach to Appeals of this kind. Before starting an appeal we will carefully consider the merits of your case and advise you on your prospects of success.
Advice and support
For more information contact one of our specialist transport lawyers at transportlaw@rotherabray.co.uk.
Send us a message

“Our experienced and specialist team represent clients nationally on a day-to-day basis”
Anton Balkitis
Head of Transport Law
stars
Posted 10 July 2026
We were extremely satisfied with the service from Rothera Bray during the process of rewriting our Wills and Side letters. Our Wills are complex and our solicitor clarified the necessary changes and took the time needed to ensure we understood the legalities involved. The service was professional but friendly.
Bob and Yvonne Bundick
stars
Posted 10 July 2026
I found Rothera Bray to be professional and responsive. I was glad I used a firm with a local office rather than one of the remote conveyancing companies.
Nigel Wright
stars
Posted 10 July 2026
Ellie has been very helpful she was always ready to answer any questions/queries I had. Nothing was too much trouble at all. Ellie’s knowledge & expertise of my situation was extremely good. She kept me informed of time frames making sure I was always updated on my completion etc. I would highly recommend Ellie to my family and friends, a very patient professional who has helped me a lot. Rothera Bray have a wonderful member of their team in Ellie Robinson.
Beverley Wyatt
stars
Posted 10 July 2026
We had the pleasure of dealing with Rothera Bray for our property purchase and specifically Tim Brooke and his team Craig Allsopp and Nikola Dzierzak. Despite a non-straightforward transaction with multiple titles, Tim and his team were excellent from start to finish, always advising us in a timely manner and doing a really thorough job on all the searches and relevant property matters. Once completion took place, Tim and team stayed engaged to ensure the title registration was complete despite the delays at land registry. We cannot thank Tim enough as at several points we thought the property deal might fall through but with the advice, guidance and attention to detail provided by Tim we got there in the end! Thank you.
Prachi
stars
Posted 9 July 2026
It’s lovely to deal with someone whom makes the process just so easy. Dealing with Talita at Rothera Bray was an absolute pleasure . Very professional and thorough.
Will client
stars
Posted 8 July 2026
George dealt with my settlement agreement, quickly and efficiently. He answered all my questions and put my mind at rest that I was doing the right thing. Thanks.
Julie R
stars
Posted 8 July 2026
The experience was very good, Millie was very knowledgeable, was quick to respond and brought the matter to a successful conclusion.
Stephen Hughes
stars
Posted 8 July 2026
Lauren provided me with exceptional support and great advice throughout my case. She is incredibly knowledgeable, friendly, and honest, making what was such a stressful process for me much easier to manage. I'd highly recommend her to anyone who might need her services.
Employment Law client
stars
Posted 7 July 2026
The conveyancing process was smooth from start to finish. Everything was handled efficiently, communication was clear, and the team was polite and professional throughout. I really appreciated how straightforward they made the whole process. Ellie Robinson and Grace Millward Thank you for a great service!
Zak Appleby
stars
Posted 6 July 2026
Thank you to everyone for all your help over a long period of time. Your mannerism and efficiency to solve each issue was most impressive. I have recommended your services to others .What was going on in the background certainly tested my patience and you kept the ship running smoothly.
Daniel P
stars
Posted 6 July 2026
We have recently purchased a property and had the pleasure of working with Fatima Altaf for our conveyancing needs. She was superb from start to finish, she worked extremely hard and was always professional, friendly and in regular contact with us throughout to make sure we were up to date and well informed of the process. Moving house with a small baby in tow is a tricky process with lots of plates to juggle, but Fatima’s confidence and competence really did make it easier for us and we felt safe and in very good hands with her. We are very impressed and wouldn’t hesitate to use Rothera Bray again in the future.
Hannah Sullivan
stars
Posted 6 July 2026
I cannot thank Chelsey and the team at Rothera Bray LLP enough for their outstanding support. We were facing a highly stressful motoring matter involving a Section 172 allegation alongside a speeding offence, which originally arose because we never received the initial NIP / request to provide driver details in the post. Chelsey was incredibly efficient, swift and proactive. Thanks to her exceptional legal expertise, she acted immediately to negotiate with the Prosecution, successfully getting the Section 172 charge completely withdrawn before the court date. She resolved the speeding offence smoothly without requiring our personal attendance in Court and secured an incredibly favourable outcome (minimum penalty points and zero prosecution costs). Her communication was clear, fast, and deeply reassuring throughout the entire process. I would highly recommend Chelsey and her firm to anyone who requires legal assistance with motoring matters.
W Cheng

Natalie Abbott
Partner & Head of Employment
Natalie works in our Nottingham office. She is a Partner and Employment Law specialist with over 10 years’ experience representing both businesses and individuals across a range of employment services including settlement agreements, discrimination, dismissals and redundancy.

Anton Balkitis
Partner & Head of Transport
Anton Balkitis leads the Transport Law team and is a nationally recognised Transport and Motoring Law specialist at Nottingham-based law firm Rothera Bray Solicitors.

Olivia Maginn
Barrister & Senior Associate
Olivia Maginn is a transport and motoring law specialist at our Lace Market, Nottingham office.

Georgina Power
Associate Solicitor
Georgina Power is an Associate Solicitor in Rothera Bray’s Transport team and is based at our Lace Market office in Nottingham city centre.

Chelsey Sewell
Managing Paralegal
Chelsey Sewell is a paralegal in Rothera Bray’s transport and motorist offence department and is based at our Nottingham Lace Market office in the city centre.

Rebeca Large-Rodriguez
Paralegal
Rebeca Large-Rodriguez is a Paralegal in Rothera Bray’s Transport and Motorist Offence department and is based at our Lace Market office.