Landlord and Tenant Disputes
Landlord and tenant dispute solicitors
The law regarding landlord and tenant responsibilities and obligations can be complex.
Our dispute resolution team offers specialist advice to both landlords and commercial property tenants.
We can advise either party on their rights and obligations where there is a dispute.
We take time to understand the issues surrounding a claim on behalf of either landlord or commercial tenant, before advising on the best approach to resolve the issue quickly, minimising the impact and cost.
What are the most common causes of landlord and tenant disputes?
Some of the most common causes of disputes between landlords and tenants are:
- Tenants not paying their rent: in some cases this may be because repairs they have requested be carried out to the property have not been completed by the landlord
- Property repairs: tenants have the right to expect the property to be safe and in good condition. If the roof starts leaking or the boiler breaks, they may request that the landlord fix it, but disputes can arise if the landlord does not make repairs quickly or accuses the tenants of causing the damage.
- Damage to the property: whilst some wear and tear is expected, disputes can arise over whether something broke because it was old and needed replacing, or whether the tenant broke it through misuse
- Deposit disputes: the tenant might dispute the amount the landlord has deducted from the deposit for repairs, or the landlord might fail to return the deposit promptly
Can I evict a tenant?
To evict a tenant from your property you can serve a Section 8 notice. This is used when the tenant has breached their agreement, such as rent areas, or there are discretionary grounds for removal, like they have neglected the property.
Do I need to have a tenancy agreement?
It is recommended to have a tenancy agreement which sets out the landlord’s responsibilities and the rules for tenants living in the property.
While the tenancy agreement can be written or verbal, having a written agreement is advised as it means there is less ambiguity, and it can easily be referred to if any disputes arise.
If you do not have a formal tenancy agreement, both parties will still have assumed rights and responsibilities. For example, it is the landlord’s responsibility to provide a safe environment for tenants and it is the tenants’ responsibility to maintain the property and pay the rent on time.
What can I do if a tenant refuses to leave the property?
Your first step should be to serve the tenant with a Section 8 notice if they have breached the terms of their tenancy agreement.
If the tenant still refuses to leave, you can take them to court. The court will look at the evidence and provide you with a possession order to reclaim the property.
If the tenant does not leave after the possession order has been granted, you can apply for a warrant of possession which allows bailiffs to remove the tenants from the property.
Who do you act for?
For residential property disputes, we act for landlords only. We do not act for residential tenants.
In commercial property, we act for both landlords and tenants.
Why use Rothera Bray for landlord and tenant disputes?
We offer advice and practical solutions for landlords and commercial property tenants in a range of areas, including:
- Pursuing residential tenants for rent arrears following possession proceedings
- Issuing proceedings and possession of commercial premises
- Issuing the appropriate notice and applying for new tenancy for either the landlord or tenant in commercial premises
- Enforcement of covenants
- Dilapidations claims, for the landlord or commercial tenant
- Residential tenancies: serving the appropriate notices and issuing proceedings to gain possession on behalf of the landlord
As well as disputes and litigation, we also provide a number of other services for residential landlords. Find out more here:
Residential Landlord Services
Send us a message
“We strive to make every matter as stress free as possible”
Richard Bates
Head of Landlord & Tenant
Richard Bates
Partner & Head of Dispute Resolution
Richard Bates leads the Dispute Resolution team at Rothera Bray. Richard is a litigation specialist and can provide a wide range of services to both commercial and private clients.
James Carley
Partner
James is a Partner in the Dispute Resolution department and is very experienced in dealing with commercial and personal litigation matters.
Terhi Sygrove
Recoveries Manager
Terhi Sygrove is a debt recovery specialist and head of the debt recovery department at our Lace Market, Nottingham Office.
Buying an expensive horse: key legal pitfalls every purchaser should know
Purchasing a high-value horse is often as much an emotional investment as it is a financial one. However, when significant sums are involved, it is vital to approach the transaction with a clear understanding of the legal framework. Disputes commonly arise around deposits, failed trials, instalment arrangements, and what happens if the horse later proves unsuitable.
People Focus: Rebecca Lee – Wills & Probate
Meet Associate Solicitor Rebecca Lee, from our Wills and Probate department based at our Leicester office. Getting into law was sparked by family influences and the stories she heard. Here, she shares a look at her career so far, from standout achievements to the hobbies and causes that mean the most to her.
Commercial property deal for new children’s play centre in Market Harborough
Rothera Bray has advised KYMM Ltd, trading as Sprog, on its first commercial property transaction, securing premises for a new children’s indoor play, retail and café destination at Wellington Place Local Centre in Market Harborough.
Meet the Team: getting to know our Family Law colleagues
Since joining Rothera Bray in January 2026, Julie McCrery, Sophie Spreckley and Jack English have become an integral part of the Family Law team. Having worked closely together for several years before joining the firm, they brought with them a wealth of experience and a strong working relationship.
Why a public inquiry into Jeffrey Epstein’s UK activities must remain on the table
Recent reports have reignited debate over whether a public inquiry into Jeffrey Epstein’s activities in the UK should take place, following apparently conflicting messages from the Government on the issue. The developments have prompted renewed calls for transparency, accountability and answers for survivors.
How to ask for a settlement agreement
Many employees reach a point where the working relationship has broken down and staying feels impossible. In the right circumstances, you may be able to ask for a settlement agreement and negotiate a clean exit.