Equine Disputes
Owning and riding a horse comes with its risks. Even if you have taken steps such as;
• Drafting an appropriate ownership agreement, or
• Having insurance in place
Disputes can still arise.
As such, a proper knowledge of equestrian law is vital in understanding your rights and responsibilities.
At Rothera Bray, our equine solicitors can help at whatever stage. Whether you are buying or selling a horse or are in dispute with a co-owner.
Our knowledge of equine law and commercial law means we are well placed to provide tailored advice.
Caroline Bowler heads up our equine law team. Caroline is experienced in using alternative dispute resolution methods to resolve disputes. As well as traditional court proceedings where needed.
Call our Equine Law Team Email our Equine Law Team
I have bought a horse that is lame – can I make a claim against the seller?
This depends on the terms stated in the contract of sale and what you agreed with the seller.
In England and Wales, the law relating to the sale of goods applies when purchasing horses. An agreement for the sale of a horse will include both;
- Terms that were specifically agreed between the parties (“express terms”) and
- In certain circumstances terms implied by law (“implied terms”)
If;
- You bought a horse for a particular purpose, such as competing in a certain event, and
- You made this known to the seller before buying the horse
It will be an implied term of the agreement that the horse was fit for that purpose. As such, the seller may be liable if the horse is lame and not fit for the purpose that you made clear to the seller.
My horse has injured someone. Am I liable?
The injured party can bring a claim under the Animals Act 1971.
However, horses can be unpredictable and sometimes cause injuries. Also, the law around animals causing damage can be difficult to understand. As a result, the Court will use a three-stage test to determine if the owner of the horse is liable.
First, the injured party needs to establish that;
- The horse was likely to cause damage unless restrained, or
- If the horse caused damage, it was likely to be severe
Next, the claimant must prove that the damage caused by the horse;
- Was due to behaviour that is not usually found in horses, or
- Only found in horses in particular circumstances, which may require expert evidence.
Finally, factual evidence will be needed to determine whether the behaviour which caused the injury or damage was known to the owner.
What rights do you have when buying a horse?
If the sale of the horse is between a trader and consumer, you will have some protection under the Consumer Rights Act 2015.
This automatically implies that the horse;
- Must be of satisfactory quality
- Fit for purpose, and
- Sold as described, both at the time of the sale and delivery
You have 30 days to reject the horse and claim additional losses if:
- There is a breach in its quality
- Fitness for purpose, or
- If it’s not as described
This starts from the date of receipt.
If you do not reject the horse within 30 days, then under the Act you must exercise a right of repair or replacement at the seller’s expense.
Will I have to go to court to resolve an equine dispute?
In most cases we can resolve equine disputes using alternative dispute resolution methods.
If your case goes to court our Equine Law specialists have considerable experience. in court proceedings. We will be able to support and guide you through every step.
Why use Rothera Bray for equine disputes?
We can provide advice on:
- Horse sale and purchase disputes
- Co-ownership disputes
- Veterinary negligence disputes
- Livery yard disputes
- Faulty equestrian equipment
- Disputes relating to the Animal Act 1971
- Horse riding accidents
- Horse loan agreements
- Horse sale or purchase agreements
Rothera Bray LLP are Official Legal Partners to British Dressage and The British Show Pony Society
Send us a message
“We’re specialists in equine disputes”
Caroline Bowler
Equine Solicitor
Summer holidays and children: What separated parents need to know before travelling abroad
As the summer holidays approach, many separated parents begin making plans for family holidays. Whilst these arrangements are often agreed without difficulty, disputes can arise when one parent wishes to take a child out of the country and the other parent does not consent. In some cases, parents may not realise that permission is required before making travel plans.
Firm strengthens Commercial Property team with appointment of Managing Associate
Rothera Bray has strengthened its Commercial Property offering in Derby with the appointment of experienced property solicitor Ed Postlethwaite as Managing Associate.
An open letter to Andy Burnham: we need a national public inquiry into maternity care
In an open letter to Andy Burnham, Greg Almond, Head of our Serious Personal Injury team, calls for a statutory public inquiry into maternity services across England, following the publication of the Ockenden Review and Amos Report.
Scotland moves ahead on non-surgical cosmetic procedure licensing – and England needs to catch up
The non-surgical cosmetic sector has long operated in a regulatory grey area, despite repeated calls for reform and well-documented risks. Scotland has taken the decisive step to address that gap by introducing the UK’s first statutory licensing framework for these procedures through the Non-surgical Procedures and Functions of Medical Reviewers (Scotland) Act 2026. The Act received Royal Assent on 12 May 2026.
stars
Posted 17 July 2026
Me and my partner were recommended Rothera Bray by our mortgage advisor for the purchase of our first property. From start to end, Abbey and Luisa were extremely helpful and responsive. They made the process so easy and always answered any questions we had. I would highly recommend Rothera Bray and will be definitely using them again for any future needs!
Shan Reid
stars
Posted 16 July 2026
I have recently used the service of Kerry Brown and Beccy Rodham in the conveyancing team for the sale of a property and I am currently also using their services for a transfer of ownership. The sale of the property had a few issues (one sale fell through) but Rothera Bray dealt with the whole transaction with expertise and were responsive to e-mails. Their online system was explanatory and made dealing with paperwork straightforward. Rothera Bray were proactive leading up to completion and I would highly recommend their services to others.
Ashley Parkin
stars
Posted 16 July 2026
We have just completed a difficult sale and purchase, throughout the conveyance Rothera Bray have been there for us. Joanne Clarke and Nirvair Kaur Singh worked hard to keep things on track and together with Jackie Murphy we are now safely in our new home. We would definitely have no problem recommending Rothera Bray based on our experience. Thank you
Barbara K
stars
Posted 15 July 2026
I engaged Rothera Bray for a motoring matter. They were professional, fair, honest and competent throughout - having spoken with a few other law firms, it was a very easy choice to go with them and I’m delighted that I did. Chelsey and Rebeca did an excellent job, gathering information and helping to focus on what mattered most. Anton was superb, putting me at ease “on the day”. He showed his expertise and command throughout and achieved a great outcome. Very grateful to the whole team and highly recommend.
Danny C
stars
Posted 15 July 2026
I recently dealt with Toby Byford at Rothera Bray who set up a will Trust for my father’s will. He was extremely polite and helpful throughout. He always responded promptly and answered my questions very clearly and in easy to understand language. He was very reassuring and made the whole process very straightforward. Thank you Toby.
Caroline D
stars
Posted 15 July 2026
The best experience I have ever had with solicitors. Superb from start to finish, kept me updated throughout regarding the sale of my home, were always there when I rang and really had my interests at heart. To complete in under 9 weeks was down the Rothera Bray, I can’t thank Lucy and Karen enough. I wouldn’t go anywhere else. Fee’s were really reasonable and transparent.
Greg W
stars
Posted 14 July 2026
Cannot speak highly of the team at Rothera Bray Beeston, who helped me along to get my issue resolved. Special mention goes to Jack English, who showed incredible resilience, along with a large dose of patience whilst guiding me along the way, so that the correct result was obtained. Would have no hesitation in recommending this practice for whatever legal service you require. Thank you once more!
Lee S
stars
Posted 13 July 2026
My divorce was a long drawn out process thanks to my ex-husband and Sarah made it a lot less stressful due to her professional caring nature and her expertise. Thank you.
Karen
stars
Posted 13 July 2026
We cannot thank Rothera Bray enough for the outstanding support they provided throughout our Special Guardianship Order (SGO) process. Thanks to their expertise, professionalism, and dedication, we achieved a successful outcome, and we genuinely couldn't have done it without them. A special thank you goes to Ann-Marie and Emily, who guided us every step of the way. They were always there to offer advice, reassurance, and practical support whenever we needed it. No question was ever too much trouble, and they responded to any concerns or issues incredibly quickly, giving us confidence throughout what was a very challenging and emotional process. Their professionalism, knowledge, and attention to detail are of the highest standard. They made us feel supported from start to finish and always had our best interests at heart. We are truly grateful for everything they have done for our family and would wholeheartedly recommend Rothera Bray to anyone in need of exceptional legal representation. Thank you again, Ann-Marie and Emily, for making such a positive difference to our lives.
Barbara
stars
Posted 10 July 2026
We were extremely satisfied with the service from Rothera Bray during the process of rewriting our Wills and Side letters. Our Wills are complex and our solicitor clarified the necessary changes and took the time needed to ensure we understood the legalities involved. The service was professional but friendly.
Bob and Yvonne Bundick
stars
Posted 10 July 2026
I found Rothera Bray to be professional and responsive. I was glad I used a firm with a local office rather than one of the remote conveyancing companies.
Nigel Wright
stars
Posted 10 July 2026
Ellie has been very helpful she was always ready to answer any questions/queries I had. Nothing was too much trouble at all. Ellie’s knowledge & expertise of my situation was extremely good. She kept me informed of time frames making sure I was always updated on my completion etc. I would highly recommend Ellie to my family and friends, a very patient professional who has helped me a lot. Rothera Bray have a wonderful member of their team in Ellie Robinson.
Beverley Wyatt